A co-worker/associate recently posted a blog post entitled What I had when working on Mac. After reading it, it struck me as mildly amusing. Some of the writer’s points are legitimate gripes…but not the kind of gripes that I feel are show stoppers. But the other gripes just don’t make any sense because the writer failed to offer enough information to get a clear view of why they’re legitimate gripes.
Now, before I go any further, let me just say that I am not a stranger to PC’s. In fact, before switching to Mac’s, I was a longtime PC user who worked within the IT industry as an IT Supervisor for nearly 6 years. I’ve used every single version of Windows since Windows 95 first came out. I’ve setup numerous Windows servers and have a lot of experience supporting multiple Windows workstations for small businesses up to 100 employees. Yes, I do know quite a bit about Windows.
Windows has plenty of strengths and weaknesses, as does the Mac OS. I understand that some people will simply prefer Windows over the Mac OS, and that’s just fine. However, if you’re going to complain about why one OS sucks more over the other, be prepared to backup your arguments.
Let’s take a look at some of the arguments presented by Ken, the writer of the blog post. It’s a short post; too short in my opinion to make any legit complaint.
1. the size in KB is really messy. It’s showing me 2KB for dozens of file but when uploading on ftp the real size varies quite largely.
Err…I’m not sure how this is a legitimate complaint. I mean, I use the Finder everyday and don’t have a problem at all with how it reports the size of really small files. You have to look at it from Apple’s point of view. They designed the Finder to be very, very simple; something that the average user could understand. Most people only care about the approximate size. Thus, they probably opted to have the file sizes of files smaller than 1KB or 2KB rounded up. How often does any user really need to know the actual size of a file less than 2KB? It’s a small freakin’ file! Who cares?
Now, if you really care about the reporting of accurate file sizes, you might look into a Finder alternative like Path Finder. The beauty part about the Mac is that there’s an app, utility, or script that solves just about every gripe you could have about the OS. Not every gripe can be fixed…but a lot of them can.
2. the active window doesn’t have a specific color, everything is gray, hard to make a distinction between the active window and others, especially when you have opened a couple.
Funny…I could say the same thing about Windows 7 (and Vista before it):

The two windows look almost identical except for the difference in the minimize, maximize, and close buttons in the top-right corner of each window…which is, ironically,exactly how the Mac does it!
Now, here’s the thing that has always annoyed me about Windows Vista and still with Window 7…Aero! Looking at the screenshot above, you’ll notice that all the windows and even the taskbar is semi-transparent with the wallpaper showing through. This to me is highly distracting. Granted, you can turn it off but I still wonder why Microsoft concentrated so much on eye candy rather than concentrating on improving the design of the windows themselves. For instance, take a look at the following window:

Now, compare this window with a typical Mac window:

The Mac window is much sleeker, more refined with less chrome; whereas the Windows window has more chrome, especially at the top, and feels more busy. Sure, the Mac window has a lot of grey…but after staring at your computer screen for hours, viewing a bunch of sleeker grey windows is much easier on the eyes than a bunch of semi-transparent busy windows in my opinion.
3. the resizing of the window is possible from only one point which is the right – bottom corner. Regularly I am working on my 24′ LCD with two windows opened (left plus right) all the time, Dreamweaver and Firefox usually. Just imagine how is to align everyday these windows to occupy the maximum space of my desktop.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. We all know this is different than Windows and, yes, we know a lot of people don’t like it. But after you spend months using a Mac you get used to it. To get around this gripe, I use a simple little app called SizeUp. It basically allows me to maximize a window to full screen, fill just half the screen, and even a quarter screen with just a simple keyboard shortcut. The result is that I can align one or more windows very quickly without fussing about with resizing a bunch of windows.
4. there is no cut file (CTRL+X) in MacOS which is a shame, such a shortcut should be cross operating systems without any doubt as it is one of the most used keyboard commands on a computer. To do the job done on a Mac you have to either open two windows and drag and drop which is actually the easy way or to drag the file on the desktop and then to drag it again where you want to move it! Grrrr!
Yeah, that’s another little thing that some people have a problem with. Many have asked why Apple has failed to offer this feature in the Finder. Honestly, I don’t know exactly what Apple’s full explanation is but it’s clear that they did it as a matter of some kind of design principle. Maybe offering just one way (copy) instead of two ways (copy and cut) to move a file and/or folder was better to them when it came to more novice users. Who knows. Personally, I complained about it for a while when I first got a Mac but now I don’t really complain about it much. You learn to live without it. But if you must have it, use Path Finder.
5. Apple Mighty Mouse is a piece of crap, the scroll ball is not working at all and for the regular scroll on web I have to click or to move the browser vertical slider. Awful!
Now, here is an issue that has absolutely nothing to do with the decision to use a Mac or not use a Mac. There are plenty of other mouses to choose from other than the Apple Mighty Mouse. If you don’t like the damn mouse then just go get another one. I personally use a Logitech mouse and keyboard on my Mac. Why, oh, why anyone would choose to not use a Mac just because of a shitty mouse is beyond me. Next gripe!
6. The computer speed is not that good as you might read on Mac reviews. Until you will use a Mac at its full performance parameters, at what point, I guess a Mac will beat a PC, it’s hard to believe that using a Mac instead a PC will make any difference.
To make a comparison at a bigger scale is like using two cars, a regular car and a Mustang – the Mustang will really make a good score on a speed track but on a regular street, both will ride with the same speed.
Like I said, a Mac probably will make a (big) difference if you are a video gamer programmer and need a super-duper computer or working in other fields which required a lot of power. For the daily – regularly use I strongly believe a PC is the best fit.
Err…right. I have way too many questions about this gripe but I’ll try and touch on the obvious ones.
First, what Mac are you using? There’s a big difference between a Mac mini, an iMac, and a Macbook Pro when it comes to performance. The same applies to PC’s: there’s a big difference between a cheap ass $500 desktop PC and a $2000 Sony laptop, wouldn’t you say? No pun intended but I think you’re trying to compare apples with oranges. I would need to know what Mac you’re using and what the specs are before I can legitimize your gripe.
Second, if you’re a video game programmer, you’ll likely be using a PC anyways…that is, unless you’re programming for games on the Mac. What you should have said is that if you’re a video editor, a graphics designer, or a 3-D animator, a Mac will likely be a good fit for you. If all you’re doing is checking email, surfing the web, and writing the occasional document or spreadsheet then any computer will do. It’s a matter of personal preference at that point. But to say that a Mac isn’t good for everyday use is ridiculous. Again, it’s all about what you prefer.
It’s a shame that the writer of the blog post didn’t write a more lengthy explanation of his gripes. If he did his point of view would have been much clearer. My point of this blog post is to illustrate the importance of looking at things from different angles. You can’t just simply say “I hate this!” and expect people to take you at your word. You have to provide constructive criticism with examples. Doing so allows for a much more educated debate. Don’t you think? :)